Home About Us Feedback Download
     Advanced Search  
May 23, 2013
 India
National
Politics
Business
Sports
Sci-Tech
Entertainment
Travel
Health
Religion
Art - Culture
Diaspora
Education
 International
Pakistan
Rest of South Asia
Asia
Americas
Europe
Australasia
Gulf-Middle East
Africa
World
  Home » National   E-mail this to a friend   Printable version
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Voices rise against 'unfair' verdict in Indian student's case
3/20/2012 10:19:00 AM

Washington, March 20 (IANS) As an online petition to the White House suggesting Indian American student Dharun Ravi was prejudged and declared guilty by media gathered momentum, more voices were heard across the US against what is seen as an unfair verdict.

Ravi, a former Rutgers University student charged with spying on his gay roommate Tyler Clementi, was found guilty by a New Jersey jury of 15 counts including invasion of privacy and bias intimidation. He faces ten years in prison and deportation to India.

By Monday night the petition asking the Obama administration to address the fact that media is driving Justice System's decisions and 18 year old Rutgers student Dharun Ravi is NOT Biased, had gathered 2,000 signatures. It must get 25,000 signatures within a month to get a White House response.

Commenting on the verdict, Sunil Adam, editor, The Indian American, wrote in the Huffington Post: Ravi, it appears, has been turned into the proverbial sacrificial lamb for society's collective guilt about its own bias intimidation against homosexuals.

Make the Punishment Fit the Cyber-Crime, exhorted Emily Bazelon, a senior editor at Slate, writing in the New York Times.

The idea of shielding vulnerable groups is well intentioned, she said. But ... these civil rights statutes are being stretched to go after teenagers who acted meanly, but not violently. This isn't what civil rights laws should be for.

Some experts, cited by msnbc.com called the guilty verdict against Ravi precedent setting in the battle against bullying, but others decried it as entering the realm of vengeance.

This is well beyond looking for justice and into the realm of vengeance considering the number of charges against Ravi and the seriousness of them, Bill Dobbs, a longtime gay activist and civil libertarian was quoted as saying.As hate crimes prosecution mount, the flaws of such laws become apparent, he wrote.

However, Louis Raveson, a law professor of criminal and civil trial litigation at Rutgers School of Law-Newark, suggested It will be an important precedent throughout the country.

Meanwhile, Marc Poirer, an openly gay professor of law and sexuality at Seton Hall University School of Law in New Jersey, said he was concerned about the verdict.

I think that the law didn't fit very well, he said, calling Ravi's actions those of a dumb 18-year-old that went wrong.

(Arun Kumar can be contacted at arun.kumar@ians.in)

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    E-mail this to a friend   Printable version
Top News
  Devotees take holy dip at natural ...
  Do women get two types of orgasms ...
  Kids of married parents less like ...
  Liberace role meant so much after ...
  Food-inspired clothing like butch ...
  'Scientists, engineers must join ...
  'Retiring' Kirsten hopes to 'go o ...
  Tamara Ecclestone opens up about ...
  Dannii Minogue struggled with lif ...
  Steven Spielberg to executive pro ...
 
World News
  12 killed, 17 injured as bomb hit ...
  South African MP says Prez Zuma r ...
  Lydia Davis pips Indian writer U. ...
  Sonia Gandhi, Nooyi among Indians ...
  North Korea sends envoy to China
  Angela Merkel tops Forbes 'Most P ...
  Pakistan: Blasphemy conundrum
  Top 10 qualities of 'exceptional' ...
  Talks with Taliban prerogative of ...
  Cameron vows to fight terrorism f ...
 
Advertisement 
National|Politics|Business|Sports|Sci-Tech|Entertainment|Travel|Health|Religion|Art - Culture|Diaspora|Education|
Pakistan|Rest of South Asia|Asia|Americas|Europe|Australasia|Gulf-Middle East|Africa|World|
Help | Site Map | Disclaimer | Privacy Policy | Publishers

©2013 southasianews.com, All Rights Reserved
© 2013 Saavn LLC. All rights reserved.